Continuing, Hinnells has less to say on the subject of the scorpion, but does continue in the same this creature is not evil vein, railing against Cumont’s Zoroastrian theory. And again, the ‘facts’ are there if we strip off our old lenses.
I can’t find the tauroctony I want, so we’ll come back to it, but the reason I’m looking for it is to show Cautopates holding a scorpion (in my mind he’s holding it like a stuffed animal.) The creature is larger than normal, because, let’s face it, scorpions aren’t that big (thank heaven!!) But it’s not the only example of a scorpion with or in place of Cautopates.
Without getting into too much detail on this now lost tauroctony (I’m bettin’ it’ll be its own report at some point) this very creative rendering shows the boys off to the side, but within the actual tauroctony the artist went with a shorthand rendering of them that doubtless members of the cult would recognize: a fruitful tree, downward torch and scorpion for Cautopates, and a barren tree, upward torch and bull’s head for Cautes. These are marked with the letters V and X respectively.

But we can go one better! Let’s take a walk through a tauroctony!
Welcome to Mitreo degli Animali in Ostia. On the floor you can see the major parts of a tauroctony rendered as mosaics. (The link shows the creatures in greater detail and I invite you to take a look.)

You enter on the mosaic of the naked conglomerate figure of Pater and Lion. He’s holding both a sickle and a fire shovel. Turning right toward the altar, you encounter a cock and a raven. Everyone is doing double duty here, the cock being Sol and Cautes (a not uncommon attribute), the raven representing the grade and being the messenger of Sol. Next, the scorpion is both Cautopates and the scorpion in the tauroctony. Okay, the snake isn’t anything but a snake, my bad. And then we get to the bull and the knife what done the deed.
At no point are these scorpions threatening. And I don’t think it’s a case of the artist not being up to the challenge of rendering a scorpion about to strike. There’s plenty of other details that are just as delicate and yet presented…the dog’s tail, for example, or the body of the snake. It doesn’t matter if these details survived to the present day or not, what matters is that they were carved and there is no reason to doubt a threatening tail could have been done as well.
Hinnells lists the deities whose attribute is a scorpion: Heremes, Serapis, Isis, Mercury and Artemis. He calls the scorpion a symbol of abundance and good fortune, pointing out that it is often used in amulets that guard against poisons and the evil eye. In the zodiac, when aligned with the human body, Scorpio’s position is on the genitals, which, at this point, should surprise no one.

The happy conclusions is, here’s another chance to look at the tauroctony, but with new eyes… while I continue to look for the one I want…



